Laptops & Mobile Phones: Creating the New Deficit In Our Kid’s Lives

Last week I was reading a fascinating article at The Daily Beast on the use of technology and some of the new research on the impact it is having on our lives. The article was called “Is the Web Driving Us Mad?”

In the entire 5 page article, one little line really stuck out to me. In talking about the use of laptops and phones they write:

“Children describe mothers and fathers unavailable in profound ways, present and yet not there at all.” (bottom of pp. 4)

I believe this statement really resonated with me because it confirms a lot of what I see in my work as a therapist. Parents who are there, but are not really there. Parents who are present, but just really unavailable, especially from an emotional perspective.

It’s a form of neglect that is often more difficult for people to put their fingers on because it can be so subtle and hard to explain.

It reminds me of a lot of men who say, “I don’t cheat on my wife or abuse my kids. I’m a good provider financially. What else do they want?” Well in fact, not cheating on your wife, or abusing your kids, and being a good financial provider is not enough. They want more. They want connection. They want emotional availability.

Or it reminds me a lot of some of the parents I see on the playgrounds, constantly on their phones, staring down at the screens, while their children are signaling for their attention, but never quite get it.

I had a person one time tell me that their dad was at every soccer game. He was there. But he was on his cell phone the entire game doing work. So he wasn’t really there. That dad would say he was present because he was there, but his kid would say he wasn’t available.

What all this unavailability creates in a person’s life is a type of deficit: Inadequacy or Insufficiency.

As children we are born into this world with a sense of expectation and desire for connection/attachment to our caregivers. In Contextual Family Therapy this is known as an entitlement: A term used to describe what one has coming to him/her. This is a a good thing. But to the degree that we don’t get the things that we are entitled to as children, a deficit is created. I’m not using entitlement here in a selfish way meaning, my daughter is entitled to all the candy and toys she wants. But what she is entitled to is that I pay attention to her, that I’m emotionally available, and that I’m there to meet her needs. To the degree that I can’t do these things (and parents are not perfect, so the goal is not perfection here), it creates an emotional deficit in my daughter.

If my daughter continually clamors for my attention while she is jumping on the trampoline, but I fail to acknowledge and pay attention to her…then she eventually learns not to desire or get that attention from me. She will look for it somewhere else, and perhaps in some unhealthy ways.

I think this what makes therapy so difficult for people at times. Lots of people say, “I had a good family. My parents didn’t fight. My needs were met. My parents didn’t abuse me.” But often as we pull back the layers we see a level of emotional neglect that many people are unaware of. They know something is missing, but they just can’t quite put their finger on it. It’s the person who often has a hard time connecting emotionally with their partner, or struggles with intimacy. The deficit created in their lives over a period of time often leaves them not desiring it anymore, or not knowing how to go about getting it in a healthy way.

So what does this all mean?

I’m writing this for awareness, because as a parent I have been more than guilty of staring at my phone while on the playground, or not closing my computer to engage my family. And I think the article is spot on. In many ways, our ability to be mobile with our technology has taken away some of the places of refuge in our lives where there wasn’t a struggle for our engagement with others.

When I go to the playground with my daughter I’m now being more intentional about leaving my cell phone home, or leaving it in my pocket. Leaving at home is better for me, because then I’m not wondering who just texted me when it vibrates.

When my son wants me to play Legos with him I’m paying attention to my computers being put away so he knows I’m fully engaged.

When my wife wants to talk with me/connect with me, I’m being more intentional about creating the space so we can emotionally connect (TV off, phone in other room, computer closed).

What can you be working on?

9 Comments

  1. by Michael Buckingham on July 19, 2012  9:31 pm Reply

    Great article and something I'm trying harder and harder to be aware of.

    But here's a flip side, my oldest son (19) seems to take the attention I give for granted. He always knows it has been there and always will be there, and thus doesn't seem to value it as much as I wish he did.

    Sometimes I kid my wife saying I'll make sure I work late just enough for my youngest (3) to miss his dad.

    Just seems like two sides of the coin sometimes.

  2. by Kenny Miracle on July 19, 2012  11:25 pm Reply

    This is spot on, Rhett. Even with on kid under 1 year old, I already see this happening, or at least the tendency. I'm usually an advocate for the benefits of technology, but anything that begins to interfere with true relational connection can quickly become not so good.

  3. by matt on July 20, 2012  12:21 am Reply

    Thanks Rhett,

    This is very helpful. You are really calling out something in our (my) subconscious.

  4. by Josh on July 20, 2012  10:12 am Reply

    Rhett,

    This is good and touches on a thought I had the other day while driving home from work.

    I don't want to be one of those who looks back on my childhood and says, "those were the good old days...what happened?" Meaning I remember days full of play, outdoors, until the porch light came on signaling it was time to come in. I don't want to segregate my childhood from the days my kids experience now and lament, looking on these days (their days) with contempt.

    I thought about how our instant mobile nature has everything on demand, with the trade-off being that we are always tethered.

    BUT I don't want to shelter myself & my family from what is happening in our culture now- the games, music, videos, and information that is shared, and have my kids pay the price of feeling like an outsider when their friends are talking about it at school.

    I think the solution lies in the ideas you just expressed. As a parent the best thing I can do is draw boundaries for myself, which I have not always done. I must understand and do this with purpose. Because above all I want to be emotionally connected with all my kids. I think the more connected they feel, the more confident they will be in their independence which grows as they do. And I want them to remember their childhood as the good ol days which is not, as it appears, automatic.

  5. Pingback : Fighting the Fear of Missing Out | Rhett Smith

  6. Pingback : Trends #1: The Secure Generation and Their Inattentive Parents | A THOUSAND GENERATIONS

  7. Pingback : My 40 Day Experiment Without Social Media Apps On My Phone | Rhett Smith

  8. Pingback : RHETT SMITH » Transitioning Life's JourneyMy 40 Day Experiment Without Social Media Apps On My Phone » RHETT SMITH

  9. Pingback : RHETT SMITH » Transitioning Life's JourneyFighting the Fear of Missing Out » RHETT SMITH

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.